So first off is the question, what did Watase take from Chinese history and legend for the purposes of Fushigi Yuugi? A part of this is easy. The first volume of the manga mentions that she drew heavily on The Romance of the Three Kingdoms, one of the great classics of Asian literature. I can’t speak directly to this yet, since I haven’t read it myself. It’s on the to-do list, but that list is long and long at the moment. So instead I went digging around in history proper and in mythology. Here’s what I found.
History
I drew all this material from Volume One of Joseph Needham’s Science and Civilization in China (Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1954), which has a very nice Historical Introduction. The early history of China went something like this. The earliest documented culture is the Shang Dynasty, dynasty being applied loosely here as a truely unified system was not yet in place. Anyway, it was your typical agriculturally based bronze-age culture centered around the valleys and basins of the Yellow and Yangtze rivers. Only got as far West as what are now the central mountains. Curiously, there are almost no indications of a neolithic culture out of which the Shang might have built themselves; Needham, in his typically understated manner, terms this lack “provoking.” At any rate, Shang lasted from circa -1500 to -1030. Then came the Chou dynasty, which was the result of one of the NorthWestern fringe cultures (the Chou) booting out the Shang aristocracy and taking their place. The same region now became organized on pretty classic feudal lines, with land parceled out into larger or smaller estates or kingdoms or whatever you want to call them. Power shuttled back and forth among the provinces/districts, depending on who had a good monopoly on salt or iron or so forth at any given time. The economic competition found further expression in military competition, and between -480 and -221 was the period known as the Warring States when everyone was fighting everyone else. By -221, though, the Chhin district, which was West of the lower Yellow River, had subjugated everyone else, partially because that district’s intense need for irrigation led to advanced engineering projects and the kind of higher organization such a project requires. It gave Chhin a substantial advantage. This was the First Unification, under Chhin Shih Huang Ti. -221 to -207 is termed the Chhin Dynasty, but while his son ascended the throne he didn’t keep it long enough to count in my opinion. See, Chhin had resorted to some pretty draconian and oppressive measures to get an empire organized, and while he succeeded in pulling it all together such harsh measures made for unrest pretty quickly. So, after a few years of infighting, one of the generals came out on top and founded the Han dynasty, which ran from -202 until +220. Han was characterized by milder government, but continued the process of taking land away from private citizens and making everyone tenants of the Emperor. Rent equalled taxes (tithes of the harvest), which were delivered to the capital. The Legalist philosophers that Chhin favored survived in this much–the emphasis was on productivity. The Han Dynasty was where the beauracracy took hold, though, and this government strongly favored Confucianism…to the extent that other philosophies were supressed among officialdom. This was the period that really set the pattern for pretty much all succeeding Chinese history up until +1912, when the Republic was formed. Power was something gained through having office, and therefore having access to both imperial favors and the tax revenues as they came into the capital (skimming seems to have evolved into a recognized way of life for the offical class). This was the beginning of the famous civil service exams–although at this early date those seem to have consisted of oral exams in how well examinees remembered classic literature (read, Confucian texts).
All good things must end, though, and after four hundred years the Han could no longer hold the empire together. For the half century or so between +221 and + 265 we have the period known as the Three Kingdoms, San Kuo. This is the period Fushigi Yuugi is more or less set in. In reality, the empire split into three roughly co-equal kingdoms, centered around the Yellow River valley in the North, the Yangtze River valley in the East-central region and the Szechuan basin (which drains into the Yangtze) in the West. Those are, in fact, the recurring geo-economic divisions all through China’s history. These kingdoms fought each other constantly, creating a great drain both on the male population and on supplies of grains. This may be the most basic reason why it was so short. Nevertheless, it was a period of particular vividness in Chinese history, and a favorite location for historical dramas.
I would note, during the San Kuo period the civil service examinations lapsed; this is one of the only real historical inaccuracies I’ve found (Chiriko studying for such exams), besides the geographical. There were three kingdoms, not four, and far from being unpopulated or depressed, the Northern kingdom of Wei was the most vigorous and the one that eventually re-subsumed the others. The economic and political power of the area around the Yellow River is something of an historical constant. It was, however, a huge area, and if there had been a fourth kingdom to the South both the Wei kingdom and the Western kingdom that centered on the Sezchuan basin would indeed likely have been much larger than any theoretical Konan-analogue so that part is pretty accurate.
My best guess is that Konan was actually intended as a loose analogue to the Yangtze region. There’s a map overlay shown when Nakago is talking about his erstwhile ambition to unite all four kingdoms. The four god seals are shown converging on a very recognizable point: the lower bend of the Yellow River, the site of the old capitals like Chang’an. If this is the point where the districts are supposed to conjoin, then Konan would seem to fall in the inland half of the Southern district.
So, on to legendry
Myth and Legend
This material I took from E.T.C. Werner’s Myths and Legends of China (New York: Dover, 1922). By Needham’s standards of Sinology Werner is merely passable, but his mistakes all seem to be in the area of his sociological interpretations. The actual material he records is creditable. If you ever read his Sociological Introduction, just keep your salt shaker handy. The man was a Brit in China in the 1920s; he was a wanker, that almost goes without saying. Altogether, this book makes a good general reference.
So, here’s what I found about the four animals and twenty-eight constellations.
First off, there seem to be several myths that have become conflated with one another. The earliest (-Fourth and -Fifth centuries [72]) is the story (well, stories, really) of Nu Kua. She is the sister of Fu Hsi, the legendary First Emperor of China–he’s placed in the five hundred years before we have any concrete evidence for anyone. Anyway, she’s credited with the creation of humans by molding them from clay and with the repair of the world. A rebel lord tried to undermine either her rule or Fu Hsi’s, depending on the version, and upon being defeated by her tried to break down a mountain or bamboo plant (again, varying by version) that formed an axis mundi. This instability tore the heavens. Nu Kua took stones of the five colors (green, red, white, black and yellow), ground them into paste, and patched the heavens with that paste. She also cut off some tortise legs to make pillars to hold the heavens up, but that’s beside our point here (81-2).
A later myth figure (+Fourth century [79]) is P’an Ku, a different creator. He is credited with creating all the world and creatures in it, and is often portrayed surrounded by four supernatural creatures: phoenix, unicorn, tortise and dragon (76). Yes, there’s a tiger missing and a unicorn horning in; we’ll get to that.
Yet another myth that I think comes in here is that of the Taoist gate guardians, the Blue Dragon and the White Tiger. These were originally heroes in battle, who, being defeated and killed in a suitably heroic manner, were given “the kingdom of the Blue Dragon Star” and “White Tiger Star” respectively to rule (148). As their description implies, they are the guardians of Taoist temple gates.
What I think may have happened, though this is total speculation on my part, is that these three stories got mapped on to each other. We have a tiger in the West instead of a unicorn because of the Taoist gate guardians–the tiger goes across from the dragon. The unicorn now floating around gets bumped into the center. Then the two creative figures get mushed together, and the colors of the stones get mapped onto the animals: green dragon, red phoenix, white tiger, black tortise and yellow unicorn. Yellow being the imperial color, and the center being the imperial position, this all works out nicely. Similarly, since a white tiger is already associated with a blue dragon, and since I believe the same word is used for blue and green in written Chinese (which is the only stable version), those fit in neatly too.
As far as the twenty-eight constellations, Werner did have some interesting tidbits. Namely, the Horned (SuBoshi), Room (SoiBoshi), Tail (AshitareBoshi), Seive (ChirikoBoshi), Bushel (MiBoshi), House, Wall, Mound, Stomach, End, Bristling, Well (ChichiriBoshi), Drawn-bow (MitsukakeBoshi) and Revolving are propitious while Neck (AmiBoshi), Bottom (TomoBoshi), Heart (NakagoBoshi), Cow, Female, Empty, Danger, Astride, Cock, Mixed, Demon (TamahomeBoshi), Willow (NurikoBoshi), Star (HotohoriBoshi) and Wing (TasukiBoshi) are unpropitious (191). The Japanese constellation names here, some of which I’m not one hundred percent sure I got with the right translation, were drawn from Renshaw and Ihara’s Star Charts and Moon Stations. Obviously, Watase ignored this in the interests of having a good side and a bad side. Probably just as well. Also, the planets Venus, Jupiter, Mercury, Mars and Saturn are marked out as locations occupied by divinities called the White, Green, Black, Red and Yellow Rulers (192). Interesting, ne? I think this may be why I’ve seen associations made between the beasts and these planets, though Werner doesn’t say whether these Rulers are ever associated with any animals.
Just as an aside, I’ve been trying to find anyone Taiitsukun might be associated with. One I’ve found so far is Hsi Wang Mu, the Golden Mother of the Tortise, who rules over a mystical and paradisical domain somewhere in the Western mountains only to be found by the deserving. This strikes me as a bit far fetched, though, since Hsi Wang Mu is supposed to be the perfect expression of yin, formed from the purest principle of the Western Air (136). Taiitsukun is too mean to be her. Besides, Nakago tells us that Taiitsukun is the perfect expression of yang, while the glowing eyes he has called upon are the expression of yin (Ep 25). So maybe they eyes are Hsi Wang Mu and Taiitsukun is actually Mu Kung, also known as Tung Wang Kung, I Chung Ming and Yu Huang Chun, “the purest substance of the Eastern Air, and sovereign of the active male principle yang and of all countries of teh East. His palace is in the misty heavens, violet clouds form its dome, blue clouds its walls” (136). The colors match up, at least. Why Taiitsukun should present female while the glowing eyes definitely sound male, if this is this case, I haven’t the foggiest.
Another possibility is the god of the North Star or possibly the North Pole. This god, according to one source, is found represented as both male and female. Werner says that the highest star god, who rules over the others, is seated at the North Pole (176). Both sources suggest that this god is in charge of the length of human life and/or the moment of death. All this does match up reasonably well with Taiitsukun’s moments at the end of the series proper. The Nyan-Nyan state that Taiitsukun is Lord of the Stars and controls death, when the living Suzaku types want to know how their dead companions came back. We also have that rather strange twenty seconds or so, when everyone is being drawn back to their proper worlds, when Taiitsukun’s voice transforms from a woman’s to a man’s and she/he is suddenly shown looking rather Imperial, much younger, male, and surrounded not by green-haired chibis but by tall and elegant green-haired young women.
Then, too, P’an Ku might be a good bet after all. If you look closely at Taiitsukun’s great mirror, you can see all four holy beast seals around it (Ep 12). Recall that P’an Ku is often shown surrounded by holy beasts. Though Taiitsukun is identified as the “controller of the world” rather than the creator (Ep 3).
I very much doubt that any of these associations are direct, or even intentional. According to Watase’s Secrets of Fushigi Yuugi notes (see translations at Tenkou, nee Tasuki, no Miko’s site), Taiitsukun is a Creator, which neither Hsi Wang Mu nor the North Polar god(s) are. In addition, there’s no direct translation of names. Tai, in both Chinese and Japanese, is a superlative–great more or less. It shows up in a lot of Chinese god names as well as in Taoist cosmological terms. I’ve found two characters for itsu; one means when or how soon and the other means be lost, peace, hide, mistake, beautiful, in turn. Of course, I don’t know how Taiitsukun is spelled, but that second seems like a good bet. Watase notes that kun in both Taiitsukun and Seikun is simply a very formal ‘you’ used as a suffix; somewhat the same way one might use -sama I would guess. So, really, Taiitsukun is probably a miscellaneous Great High God type whose antecedents are untraceably vague. I still had fun looking.
So, anyway, on to what Watase does with her borrowings and why she might have chosen these, in particular, in the first place.
Romanticism
With a big R. As if the information that this world that’s “very like Ancient China” is based on The Romance of the Three Kingdoms wasn’t a tip off. But Japan has its own Romantic and picturesque eras, both imperial (Heian) and feudal (Edo). Why should Watase go abroad? One possibility I can think of is a desire for exoticism. But what if Watase wanted to make a point about the desire for exoticism itself, or Golden Age Syndrome? You see, China, and ancient China in particular, was the source from whence Japan acquired some significant cultural tools, like standardized transcription (kanji), beauracracy, and a passel of philosophical systems like Confucianism. China dominated pretty much all of South Eastern Asia, culturally and sometimes politically, for a rather long time, and Japan was not exempt from this trend. There was even a time, during late Heian if I recall correctly, when Japan was yet another suzerainity of China. There are two attitudes toward China that I’ve seen in Japanese literature and rhetoric, both of which I think stem from this. One is the sort of inferiority complex you can find in the States regarding Europe. The other, I tend to consider a backlash to the first, and this one can more or less be translated as “we are so much better and more bad-assed than you.” (Also parallel to States attitudes, now I think of it.) I suspect both are actually in play in FY. On the one hand, this other world is clearly pretty primitive with wars everywhere and…colorful sorts like bandits and slavers running rampant. On the other, it’s also full of mysticism and ritual, refinements like really wonderful baths and larger-than-life heros. Remember the first thing Miaka says about Konan’s capital, as she wanders around: “everyone is so full of life” (Ep 1).
That is, after all, one of the things Romanticism is all about–the idea that the past was better or more graceful or more vivid than the present.
The part that interests me about all this is what Watase does with this Romantic world and its denizens. Tamahome, one of our foremost Romantic figures, winds up in the real (present) world. This causes problems–an imbalance. That says to me that Watase wants us to understand that while Romance is all very well in a book it really can’t be translated into real life. Now, Tamahome does, eventually, appear in the real world to stay, but we should note that he isn’t Tamahome anymore, at least not in the original manga story. He’s Taka. And he wasn’t just given a cosmetic name change, he was retroactively reincarnated as a whole nother person with the life and experience to belong in the real world (more on the issue of experience and reality on the Fascination page). That says to me that Watase is a proponent of compromise. The figure of romance can exist in reality, provided he’s first filtered through real life. Perfect Romance, no. Some romance, yes.
If we extend this to the issue of China, we can also read Tamahome’s reinscription as Taka as a comment on the proper way to treat the cultural tools Japan inherited from China. They need to be adjusted, filtered through the existing Japanese systems. And then they won’t really be Chinese any more, but something else. What a lovely little parable of assimilation! At the same time, it’s a warning about the dangers of becoming unbalanced by too much nostalgia or desire for the exotic.
Watase emphasizes the return from the Romantic very strongly, especially for a story that’s all about how bright and vital that other world is. One of the crucial points made in that last battle is that Yui and Miaka have learned to love and value their real world enough to defend it (Episode 50).