Branch (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
branchandroot) wrote2007-01-23 12:39 pm
branchandroot) wrote2007-01-23 12:39 pm
Entry tags:
GB world assumptions
Catching up on Getbackers summaries.
I see a lot of people suggesting the manga will end just like the anime. Clearly, it can't end /just/ like, because the characters are dispersed in different ways. I could see a very similar ending, of turning back from power/knowledge in favor of companionship, and basically hitting the world-reset thereby. But one basic point keeps nagging at me.
In the anime, there is an implicit assumption that the world outside Mugenjou is real. In the manga, starting with the card arc and accelerating since, there is an implication that it is not. Whether this will culminate in some kind of statement about what reality is or unravel in a lot of messy loose ends, I don't know. (And if this whole thing turns out to be some kind of virual reality and the 'archive' is the entry/exit point, well that would be consistent but it would also be a total cop out.) So the ending can't be as simple as it was in the anime.
I will actually be rather disappointed if Ban lives through his current contretemps. The fact that a fourth use of the Jagan results in backlash, in the erasure of the user, implies that there is some kind of natural limit on how the reality of others may be manipulated--if you do it too much or too often, the recoil will contain and erase you from the world and the memories of those you have dealt with. If he lives after having used it too often, that will imply that the Brain Trust is right, that limits can and should be broken, and will lend validation to all the really appalling things they've done in order to make humans 'evolve' or 'leap forward'. After all, screwing with people's reality is what the Brain Trust is all about, witness the 'lost time' that is the current object of retrieval.
So either Ban is going to win and then die, or there's going to be a huge and infuriating ethical failure in this story, or, just maybe, the authors are going to do something completely different and pull it off while still letting Ban survive.
Also. Really, really want a good translation of issue 80, which seems to have been some explanation of Rai Tei.
I see a lot of people suggesting the manga will end just like the anime. Clearly, it can't end /just/ like, because the characters are dispersed in different ways. I could see a very similar ending, of turning back from power/knowledge in favor of companionship, and basically hitting the world-reset thereby. But one basic point keeps nagging at me.
In the anime, there is an implicit assumption that the world outside Mugenjou is real. In the manga, starting with the card arc and accelerating since, there is an implication that it is not. Whether this will culminate in some kind of statement about what reality is or unravel in a lot of messy loose ends, I don't know. (And if this whole thing turns out to be some kind of virual reality and the 'archive' is the entry/exit point, well that would be consistent but it would also be a total cop out.) So the ending can't be as simple as it was in the anime.
I will actually be rather disappointed if Ban lives through his current contretemps. The fact that a fourth use of the Jagan results in backlash, in the erasure of the user, implies that there is some kind of natural limit on how the reality of others may be manipulated--if you do it too much or too often, the recoil will contain and erase you from the world and the memories of those you have dealt with. If he lives after having used it too often, that will imply that the Brain Trust is right, that limits can and should be broken, and will lend validation to all the really appalling things they've done in order to make humans 'evolve' or 'leap forward'. After all, screwing with people's reality is what the Brain Trust is all about, witness the 'lost time' that is the current object of retrieval.
So either Ban is going to win and then die, or there's going to be a huge and infuriating ethical failure in this story, or, just maybe, the authors are going to do something completely different and pull it off while still letting Ban survive.
Also. Really, really want a good translation of issue 80, which seems to have been some explanation of Rai Tei.